Menu of Oceanside Safari Restaurant & Lounge in Islamorada, Florida, USA

Menu Overview

Oceanside Safari Restaurant & Lounge, nestled on 73814 Overseas Hwy in Islamorada, offers a compelling blend of fresh seafood, laid-back ambiance, and stunning ocean views that make it a must-visit spot in the Florida Keys. This restaurant balances classic coastal flavors with an updated, welcoming atmosphere, making it a true jewel for locals and travelers alike.

The menu shines brightest with its seafood offerings, standout dishes that leave a lasting impression. A hidden gem, the fried whole snapper, praised by one enthusiastic diner, delivers a crisp texture and bold, fresh flavors, clearly a labor of skilled craftsmanship from the kitchen. The restaurant’s dedication to quality extends beyond just the fish. The wings, mentioned with equal enthusiasm, bring home a hearty, savory experience that complements the maritime theme perfectly.

While seafood takes center stage, the menu also caters to more casual tastes. The chicken, bacon, and avocado sandwich offers a solid option, though it didn’t quite reach the heights of other dishes during my visit. However, the fried pickles are nothing short of exceptional; crispy with a perfect balance of seasoning, they offer a satisfying crunch and savory bite that stands out even among classic bar snacks. These pickles alone justify a return visit.

Drinks at Oceanside Safari add to the charm. The Painkiller cocktail is a crowd favorite, smooth and refreshing with tropical notes ideal for the Keys’ warm climate. While some cocktails like the margarita might lean toward convenience, the rye-tai caught my attention with its nuanced flavors, striking a fine balance between smoothness and a spirited kick. The happy hour menu is well-priced and diverse, enhancing the overall value of the waterfront dining experience.

The service here significantly bolsters the dining experience. Attentive and warm staff like Francine and Sonja create an inviting, team-oriented vibe that makes guests feel genuinely cared for. This level of hospitality blends seamlessly with the restaurant’s beautiful oceanfront setting, enhancing the pleasure of every meal.

Oceanside Safari has evolved impressively from its storied past. The renovations post-hurricane have transformed it from the “dead animals bar” into a polished contemporary venue that honors its local legacy while providing updated comforts. Its outdoor patio, poised for expansion, promises even more spectacular ways to enjoy views of the Atlantic.

In conclusion, Oceanside Safari Restaurant & Lounge delivers a satisfying, authentic coastal dining experience with standout seafood, solid bar fare, and a welcoming atmosphere enhanced by attentive service and breathtaking ocean vistas. Whether you come for the fried snapper or to unwind with a Painkiller and sunset, this place feels like a vibrant chapter in the ongoing story of the Florida Keys’ culinary scene.